Engagement

If you are thinking about becoming engaged, or are currently engaged, Max can discuss the issues and rights of individuals in regard to personal property, should the engagement be broken.

 

Many times, the issue revolves around the engagement ring and who is entitled to keep it.  The case of Lindh v. Surman put this issue to test.  In Lindh, an arbitration panel ruled that the wife-to-be was entitled to keep the ring.  However, the Court of Common Pleas reversed the decision, allowing the husband-to-be to keep the ring.  The Pennsylvania Superior Court affirmed the trial court's decision.

 

When the case was argued before the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, the parties agreed that the engagement ring was a conditional gift.  The court held that the gift was conditional upon marriage, not upon the acceptance of the proposal.

 

Further, the Supreme Court ruled that the "no-fault" system that governs divorce proceedings in Pennsylvania is applicable to the engagement ring dispute, citing that in order to determine who was at "fault" required a detailed inquiry into the facts surrounding the failure of the relationship and would ultimately burden the lower courts.

 

Since the "gift" of the engagement ring was conditioned on marriage, the husband-to-be was entitled to keep the ring even if he was the one to break the engagement.

​​​​© 2017 by the Law Offices of Max C. Feldman

Proudly serving the cities of Aliquippa, Arnold, Beaver Falls, Butler, Clairton, Connellsville, Greensburg, Indiana, Jeannette, Latrobe, Lower Burrell, McKeesport, Monessen, Monongahela, New Kensington, Pittsburgh, Uniontown, Washington; the boroughs of Ambridge, Apollo, Aspinwall, Avalon, Baden, Baldwin, Beaver, Belle Vernon, Bellevue, Bentleyville, Bethel Park, Blawnox, Brackenridge, Braddock Hills, Braddock, Bradford Woods, Brentwood, Bridgeville, Bridgewater, Burgettstown, California, Canonsburg, Carnegie, Castle Shannon, Charleroi, Cheswick, Churchill, Coraopolis, Crafton, Delmont, Donora, Dormont, East McKeesport, Washington, Economy, Edgewood, Edgeworth, Elizabeth, Ellwood City, Emsworth, Etna, Evans City, Export, Finleyville, Ford City, Forest Hills, Fox Chapel, Franklin Park, Freedom, Freeport, Glassport, Green Tree, Harmony, Heidelberg, Homestead, Hookstown, Houston, Irwin, Jefferson Hills, Kittanning, Leechburg, Leetsdale, Ligonier, Mars, McDonald, McKees Rocks, Midland, Millvale, Monaca, Monroeville, Mt. Pleasant, Munhall, Murrysville, New Brighton, New Stanton, Oakdale, Oakmont, Pitcairn, Pleasant Hills, Plum, Rochester, Saxonburg, Scottdale, Seven Fields, Sewickley, Shippingport, Slippery Rock, Swissvale, Tarentum, Trafford, Turtle Creek, Vandergrift, Verona, West Mifflin, White Oak, Whitehall, Wilkinsburg, Zelienople; the Allegheny County Townships of Aleppo, Baldwin, Collier, Crescent, East Deer, Elizabeth, Fawn, Findlay, Forward, Frazer, Hampton, Harmar, Harrison, Indiana, Kennedy, Kilbuck, Leet, Marshall, McCandless, Moon, Mt. Lebanon, Neville, North Fayette, North Versailles, O'Hara, Ohio, Penn Hills, Pine, Reserve, Richland, Robinson, Ross, Scott, Shaler, South Fayette, South Park, South Versailles, Springdale, Stowe, Upper St. Clair, West Deer, Wilkins, the Armstrong County Townships of Bethel, Boggs, Bradys Bend, Burrell, Cadogan, Cowanshannock, East Franklin, Gilpin, Hovey, Kiskiminetas, Kittanning, Madison, Mahoning, Manor, North Buffalo, Parks, Perry, Pine, Plumcreek, Rayburn, Redbank, South Bend, South Buffalo, Sugarcreek, Valley, Washington, Wayne, West Franklin, the Beaver County Townships of Brighton, Center, Chippewa, Darlington, Daugherty, Franklin, Greene, Hanover, Harmony, Hopewell, Independence, Marion, New Sewickley, North Sewickley, Patterson, Potter, Pulaski, Raccoon, Rochester, South Beaver, Vanport, White, the Butler County Townships of Adams, Allegheny, Brady, Buffalo, Butler, Center, Cherry, Clay, Clearfield, Clinton, Concord, Connoquenessing, Cranberry, Donegal, Fairview, Forward, Franklin, Jackson, Jefferson, Lancaster, Marion, Mercer, Middlesex, Muddy Creek, Oakland, Parker, Penn, Slippery Rock, Summit, Venango, Washington, Winfield, Worth, the Fayette County Townships of Brownsville, Bullskin, Connellsville, Dunbar, Franklin, Georges, German, Henry, Clay, Jefferson, Lower Tyrone, Luzerne, Menallen, Nicholson, North Union, Perry, Redstone, Saltlick, South Union, Springfield, Springhill, Stewart, Upper Tyrone, Washington, Wharton, the Washington County Townships of Amwell, Blaine, Buffalo, Canton, Carroll, Cecil, Chartiers, Cross Creek, Donegal, East Bethlehem, East Finley, Fallowfield, Hanover, Hopewell, Independence, Jefferson, Morris, Mount Pleasant, North Bethlehem, North Franklin, North Strabane, Nottingham, Peters, Robinson, Smith, Somerset, South Franklin, South Strabane, Union, West Bethlehem, West Finley, West Pike Run, the Westmoreland County Townships of Allegheny, Bell, Cook, Derry, Donegal, East Huntingdon, Fairfield, Hempfield, Irwin, Ligonier, Loyalhanna, Mount Pleasant, North Huntingdon, Penn, Rostraver, Salem, Sewickley, South Huntingdon, St. Clair, Unity; and the counties of Allegheny, Armstrong, Beaver, Butler, Fayette, Greene, Indiana, Lawrence, Somerset, Washington, and Westmoreland.

CONNECT WITH US:

  • Facebook - Black Circle

The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. You should consult an attorney for advice regarding your individual situation. We invite you to contact us and welcome your calls, letters and electronic mail. Contacting us does not create an attorney-client relationship. Please do not send any confidential information to us until such time as an attorney-client relationship has been established.